By Nco Dube | 19 November 2026
Before the election I wrote in the Sunday Tribune that we would vote on 4 November and the parties would horse-trade on the fifth. Here we are. The DA and its horde of supporters wants us to believe that withholding Johannesburg’s mayoral chain from Helen Zille would defy the voters. In KwaZulu-Natal two years ago, the same party helped put the clear election winner (by the DA supporters own logic in Johannesburg) on the opposition benches. It called the result a Government of Provincial Unity.
The MK Party won 45.35% of the KwaZulu-Natal provincial vote in 2024 and took 37 of 80 seats. The IFP, ANC, DA and NFP put together 41 votes and elected the IFP’s Thami Ntuli as premier. Now look at Johannesburg. Zille drove the campaign that took the DA from 71 to 91 seats in a 270-seat council. I believe the largest party in a hung council or legislature should get the first shot at forming a government. The next step is to find a majority. If somebody else finds it first, the DA can sit in opposition. The benches are perfectly good in Johannesburg, Tshwane and Ekurhuleni as they are in KZN. Ask the MK Party.
The DA can spare us the lecture about respecting the biggest party. In Johannesburg in 2021, the ANC came first with 91 seats, the DA had 71, and the DA’s Mpho Phalatse took the chain with 144 council votes. Herman Mashaba withdrew from the race and ActionSA backed her. The DA had no trouble accepting either the votes of a smaller party or a mayoralty that, by its supporters’ argument today, belonged to the ANC.
ActionSA’s votes belong to ActionSA’s voters
DA leader Geordin Hill-Lewis has questioned whether dropping Zille would respect the people who voted for her. The pressure on Mashaba carries a rather grand assumption that ActionSA’s 43 councillors owe those voters a mayor. Even if Mashaba gave the DA every one of those votes, the two parties would still be two short of a full-council majority. Presumably the next party they approach will also be told its voters meant to elect Helen Zille.
ActionSA has offered to consider a DA-led deal with a different candidate. Mashaba has proposed that he and Zille both step aside. The DA should ask why a party that helped put Phalatse in office is now willing to walk away from a deal over who leads it. Mashaba quit the DA in 2019 after Zille was elected federal council chair. In 2023, ActionSA says the DA’s federal executive killed a deal with the Patriotic Alliance that its own negotiators had accepted to save Phalatse’s administration. Phalatse lost the no-confidence vote. Coalition partners remember who can make a promise across the table and who can tear it up afterwards.
Mashaba owes his own voters an account of what he’s bargaining for. He once vowed to keep the ANC out of office. He now points to Tshwane, where ActionSA’s Nasiphi Moya became mayor with ANC and EFF support. If he wants another arrangement with the ANC, Johannesburg should see what he’ll demand on water repairs, finances and appointments. He should be just as specific about what he thinks a different DA mayor would deliver. The city has spent enough time paying for political feuds.
Two wards and still at the table
The ANC’s result in KwaZulu-Natal was brutal. The MK Party took 23 wards previously held by the ANC in Msunduzi and 16 in Newcastle. In eThekwini, the party that won 75 wards in 2021 won just two of 112 this time. The MK Party took 73. The ANC’s other 35 councillors came from the party list. That gives it 37 seats and a decisive say over who runs Durban. The ANC can go from 75 ward victories to two and still have both its rivals calling. The DA and ANC met in Durban while the ANC was also exploring a deal with the MK Party. Think what the DA is asking people to accept. In Johannesburg it invokes the voters to press its claim to the mayoralty. In Durban it’s exploring a deal with the party voters punished, and could use it to get ahead of the party that came first.
Nationally the ANC sank to 30.76%, its worst local election result, yet a record number of hung councils has given it room to bargain. In Johannesburg it fell from 91 seats to 63. It can still give the DA a 154-seat majority or join ActionSA, the EFF and the MK Party for 138 seats, just two above the majority line. The ANC learnt from 2024. Keep several talks going and make sure every party knows what the others can offer. Even a losing election can leave you in a position to choose who gets to govern. A deal with the DA might get the ANC back into a metro executive, with the DA taking credit for whatever improves. A deal with the MK Party in Durban would give the ANC a share of power under the party that has just taken much of its old ground. Neither deal gives the ANC back the support it lost.
The DA helped teach it that lesson. In 2024, after the ANC lost its parliamentary majority, DA MPs voted to return Cyril Ramaphosa to the presidency. The DA took Cabinet posts and said the deal would “enact the will of the South African people”. That was the DA’s choice. ActionSA has the same freedom today. The ANC’s council seats give it bargaining power in the metros. The DA’s decision to share power with it nationally gives the ANC another point of pressure. The people now warning Mashaba against putting the ANC back in office might direct some of that indignation at their own party.
The MK Party has a route to power
In 2024, the MK Party came four seats short of a majority in the KwaZulu-Natal legislature and failed to secure the partners it needed. This time it has a national negotiating team and has held formal talks with the ANC.
Sowetan reported an understanding in principle on municipal co-operation. In eThekwini, the MK Party and ANC have 123 of 223 seats between them. The DA, ANC and IFP would have 109 and would need another partner. The MK Party has a better plan this time. It has started talking to the people whose votes it needs while it still has something to offer them. Its first job is to turn those discussions into an agreement that can survive the allocation of posts and the first fights over spending.
A working agreement in Durban could put the provincial government under real pressure. The ANC and MK Party won 51 of the 80 legislature seats between them in 2024. If they ever agreed to replace Ntuli, they would easily pass a no-confidence vote in the legislature. At national level, an ANC that can work with the MK Party and EFF in major metros has a more credible alternative to put to its GNU partners when the next fight over the budget or policy comes. The first city budget those parties have to pass together will tell us how credible that alternative is.
In October I argued that the people who pay for failed coalitions are seldom the people who negotiate them. That is still the test. The DA has promised to publish its signed agreements. Voters should see the terms before councillors choose the mayor. Once the jobs are handed out, residents are left to police a bargain they never got to examine. Put the numbers on the table. Which water repairs get funded, by when, and who answers when the work stalls? If a majority chooses someone else in Johannesburg, the DA should take its seats in opposition. It could use the time to figure out why parties that once put it in office now think twice before taking its call.