Piccolo Teatro

Economic Freedom Without Education and Big Business?

Economic Freedom Without Education and Big Business?

It was interesting to note at a recent seminar on ‘Economic Freedom in Our Lifetime’ organised by the Xubera Institute for Research and Development, that out of all the panellists, only one mentioned the importance of education in attaining economic freedom. The panellists in included an economist, an academic, a journalist/political analyst and a Provincial MEC.

While we must live with the fact that a majority of South Africans are not highly educated and that they still have a role to play in the economy, we can not overlook the fact that very few people are gifted enough to be able to participate fully in the economy with little or no education.

Education remains the most important factor in the fit for meaningful transformation and fight for economic freedom. Without education who will be able to take advantage of the equal economic opportunities that we are demanding from the White Inc?

Credit must be given to ANCYL for bringing the issue of economic transformation to the forefront of the national agenda. Their argument is flawed though, in that they are not asking the youth to go back to school and arm themselves for the opportunities that will come with the nationalisation they are calling for. In fact, I haven’t heard the ANCYL articulating exactly how the youth will benefit?

I was also disappointed at the Xubera Seminar that amongst the panellists there was no one representing big business. Big business is part of the White Inc and one of the biggest obstacles to economic transformation.

Everyone seems to be only focusing on how Government is failing to create jobs and transforming the economy. What Government is failing to do is creating the right climate for this to happen by legislating and regulating. The bigger problem is the fight by the White Inc against transformation and their efforts at maintaining white privilege and wealth.

I wrote elsewhere on this blog about the unholy and corrupt marriage between the White Inc and some in Government. This only serves to create a few ultra rich black individuals linked to the ruling elite who hardly do anything to create jobs or grow the economy while they help ease pressure on the White Inc to transform. This is not sustainable and only buys them time.

I have even heard some in the White Inc even blaming black people of not wanting to work the land etc hence they shouldn’t be given the land. Bull, I say! Black people used to live on the land until the land act of 1930 stripped them of the land in order to make them dependent on the mining sector. This created, overnight, a bottomless pit of cheap labour for the White Inc and made sure that black people were dependent on capitalist interests forever. Government and White Inc has a duty then to couple land reform with the skilling of the beneficiaries.

It is time now to stop repeatedly talking about problems that we all know are there and doing endless analysis. It’s time to stop with “the position papers, white papers, green papers and pink papers”, as Allister Sparks put it. We now need to start doing what we can to bring about meaningful economic transformation that will not disrupt economic growth.

It starts with turning education around, even if it is done one school at the time. It starts with growing capacity in FET’s so they can be used productively to skill the millions of unemployed youth. Our education is crumbling but no one seems to be in panic mode! Black schools in the townships and rural areas haven’t seen any change in the new democratic dispensation. Teachers and their union SADTU are a huge part of the problem in black schools and this needs to change. Parents need to get involved in their children’s education.

The White Inc needs to admit that black people were denied the right to participate in the economy for a very long time and that their white counterparts are way ahead of them. In order for redress to happen, some sort of advantage needs to be given to black people so they can catch up. BEE seems to be only working for the White Inc and a few blacks linked to the ruling elite.

Continuous denial that race needs to play a role in effecting economic transformation will lead to a revolt. That revolt will not only be against government but also against the White Inc as black people feel that they are being economically suppressed by both government and the White Inc. If there is to be a Tunisia in South Africa, we all lose.

4 responses to “Economic Freedom Without Education and Big Business?”

  1. Bouga Avatar
    Bouga

    An uneducated society is beneficial to the ruling party as it is easier to manipulate. Economic freedom in our lifetime is not a bad goal in fact it is clear, measurable and seemingly attainable but I still can’t help but feel its another quick fix proposal that will leave us with egg in our faces.

    I like what you said about the Ancyl having the foresight to try and seek solutions to a very real problem but I still feel that there isn’t a one size fits all solution to our multiple problems.

    1. ncodube Avatar

      You are absolutely correct Xolani. Having a huge block of the population uneducated suits some quarters in the short term but is absolutely not sustainable. Both the ruling elite and the White Inc are well suited by the status quo in that they get voting fodder and cheap labour respectively. This though will backfire soon because the uneducated masses can be easily swayed on way or the other. It’s a matter of time until they start listening to someone else other than the ruling elite and the white Inc. It’s sad that black people are being exploited like this on both ends.

  2. mike Avatar
    mike

    Interesting read and have to agree that education is a problem , I don’t think that white inc have a conspiracy to keep black people out the problem is as you said is the poor education , business want to make money and will use whoever to get them there black or white . As long as people continue to blame other factors for the upliftment of black people and avoid the real issue of poor education , it will still be a problem . So the govt needs to improve the education system before the can be true economic transformation , charity is not going to happen

    1. ncodube Avatar

      Thanks for your comment Mike. The argument that government is solely responsible for economic transformation is flawed in that the current government did not benefit from apartheid. Their responsibility is to make sure that that there is a good legislative and regulatory climate for transformation to take place. The biggest of those responsibilities is to sort out the mess in education and they are failing dismally in that. The white Inc (please read my blogpost titled ‘White Inc’ in order to understand what the term means) and white people in general benefitted from apartheid and continue to benefit from it’s legacy at the expense of black people. They then have the responsibility to also make sure that transformation occurs. They have a responsibility to ‘give back’ in order to level the playing field. This giving back is not charity. And it is not about giving shares (like we see in BEE schemes) and directorships to people in the ruling elite and to people who are not equipped to manage such opportunities. It is about imparting skill, treating qualified and deserving people with preference in the workplace. This will not happen though until the white Inc and white people in general truly admit and acknowledge what they know to be a fact, that they got to where they are mainly because of being in a privileged position of superior education and open opportunities while blacks had what had to be the worst education in the world (Bantu education) which has now for the worst. If we do not all work on this together, we all lose. The country will burn, soon.

Leave a comment